Broken Links and 404 Errors, Cleaned Up Properly
Nothing looks wrong. The site loads, the menu works, and links inside your pages quietly send readers into dead ends.
Why broken links go unnoticed for years
Nothing visibly breaks. The page loads, the menu works, and the damage only shows up in readers who quietly leave.
-
A link gets written
Somebody guesses an address, or plans a page, or tidies a URL. It looks fine in the sentence.
-
Nothing appears to break
The site still works. Nobody complains. The dead link sits inside your best article for years.
-
The real ones get fixed
Every link checked live, the costly ones corrected at the source, and the harmless ones deliberately left alone.
Broken links are the easiest SEO problem to ignore, because nothing looks wrong.
The site loads. The menu works. Nobody complains. Meanwhile links inside your own pages point at addresses that do not exist, and every visitor who clicks one hits a dead end and leaves.
It is also one of the cheapest things to fix properly.
The Honest Version: Not Every 404 Matters
Plenty of people will sell you a panic about this. Most 404s are harmless.
The ones that do not matter
A page you deleted on purpose that nobody links to and nobody visits should return 404. That is correct. Google drops it and moves on. Redirecting every deleted page somewhere random is worse than leaving it dead.
Google has said this repeatedly and it is still the most oversold worry in SEO.
The ones that genuinely cost you
Broken links inside your own pages. Every one of those is a reader you sent into a wall, and a signal that nobody is maintaining the site.
Dead pages that still have visitors or links pointing at them from other sites. That is earned value draining away.
And links in your menu or footer, because those appear on every single page of the site at once.
What I actually fix
The ones with a cost. I will tell you which of your 404s to leave alone rather than charging you to redirect things that should stay dead.
Where Broken Links Come From
The causes are boringly consistent.
Somebody guessed the address
A writer links to a page they assume exists, or plans to write. The link ships. The page never does. This is the single most common cause I find.
Singular and plural mixed up
Linking to “services” when the page is “service”. Invisible to a human reading the sentence, completely dead to a browser.
Pages deleted without redirects
Old content cleared out and every link pointing at it left hanging.
A move that missed things
Migrations handle the main pages and forget the ones buried inside articles.
Menus and footers
One dead link in your navigation is a dead link on every page you own.
Addresses that changed
Somebody tidied a URL. Everything pointing at the old one stopped working the same minute.
How the Fix Works
1. Crawl the whole site, not the tool’s list
Plugins that track broken links keep stale records. I have seen lists where a third of the entries were already fine and the genuinely broken ones were missing. I check every link live.
2. Separate real from noise
Links inside content, links in navigation, and dead pages that still receive visitors. Everything else gets flagged and left alone.
3. Send each one to the right place
The closest genuinely useful page, not the homepage. Sending everything to the homepage is what most cleanups do and Google treats it as barely better than a dead end.
4. Fix the source, not just the symptom
Where a link is broken inside your content, the content gets corrected so the link is right at the source. Redirects are for addresses you no longer control.
A Real Example
On this site, links pointing at “semantic-seo-services” and “keyword-research-services” had been dead since the day those pages launched, because the real addresses are singular. Nobody noticed for months.
Fourteen more links pointed at guide pages that were planned and never written. They sat inside the best articles on the site.
And one dead link lived in the site navigation, which meant it appeared on every page of the site at once.
None of it broke anything visibly. All of it was costing readers.
When You Do Not Need Me for This
You have a handful of them. If Search Console shows five broken links and you can edit your own pages, fix them yourself. It is twenty minutes.
They are all external. Other people’s sites go down and change addresses. That is not your fault and mostly not your problem.
Your plugin already lists them accurately. If the list is right and you have time, the work is not difficult. I charge for finding what the tools miss, not for clicking through a list.
Price and Turnaround
Size of site |
Price |
Turnaround |
|---|---|---|
Up to 100 pages |
$149 |
2 – 3 days |
100 – 500 pages |
$249 |
3 – 5 days |
Over 500 pages |
From $399 |
1 week |
Includes the full crawl, the fixes applied, and a list of the 404s I deliberately left alone with the reason for each.
Common Questions
Do broken links hurt my rankings?
Indirectly. A few dead links will not drop you. A site full of them signals neglect, wastes Google’s time, and loses readers who would have stayed.
Should I redirect every deleted page?
No. If there is no genuinely relevant destination, a redirect is worse than a 404. Google treats an irrelevant redirect as a dead end anyway.
My plugin says I have hundreds. Is that real?
Often not. These lists go stale, count the same link many times, and flag things that were never links. I check every one before touching anything.
What about links from other sites to dead pages?
Those are the valuable ones. Somebody linked to you and the page is gone. Those get redirected first because they carry real value.
Will this stop it happening again?
Partly. I will tell you what caused yours, and most sites have one repeating habit behind the majority of them.
Not sure how many you have?
I will crawl your site for free and tell you how many are genuinely worth fixing. Usually fewer than the plugins claim.
Or email info@shazzseo.com